The review provides a detailed analysis of the “A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder” series by Holly Jackson, focusing on the impact of the storyline’s twists, especially in the third book. Initially drawn in by the TV adaptation, the reviewer enjoyed the first two books, praising Jackson’s writing and attention to detail. However, the third book’s dramatic turn left them dissatisfied, particularly with Pip’s decision to kill the “Duct Tape” Killer. The reviewer questions this choice as inconsistent with Pip’s character and expresses concern over the moral implications of such an act.
A key takeaway is the emotional journey the reviewer experiences with Pip, noting that her actions contradict the growth they had come to admire. The review reflects on themes of justice, trauma, and the consequences of one’s actions, ultimately concluding that while Pip is deeply flawed, her choice reflects a troubling direction for her character. The reviewer leaves the experience feeling conflicted about the series’ conclusion and Pip’s transformation.
