Finding the Right Care for Your Four-Legged Family
By Lourin Sprenger | Sept. 12, 2026
For pet owners, going on vacation can be anxiety-inducing as you ponder who will care for your furry friends in your absence. Finding a trustworthy caretaker is crucial and can be just as important as selecting your travel destination. We consulted two local pet sitters on how to thoroughly vet candidates to look after your pets.
In Your Place Pet Sitting
Jennifer Estala launched In Your Place Pet Sitting after a career managing a pet supply boutique in New Jersey. She established strong bonds with the dogs and their owners, which led to requests for in-home pet care.
After relocating to Michigan in 2020, Estala turned her passion into a business, building it from the ground up. “It was slow at first,” she recalls, noting that advertising sparked a rapid growth in clientele. Now, she books out nearly a year in advance and had to stop accepting new clients for a period due to high demand.
Routine and Patience
Estala believes that when owners are away, their pets should maintain their usual routines. She emphasizes in-home care, allowing pets to feel secure in their familiar environment. “If you can’t be there, I’ll be there in your place,” is a mantra that encapsulates her approach.
Her services range from overnight stays to hourly visits, tailored to each pet’s distinct needs. Estala’s individualized care is particularly beneficial for pets who are shy or anxious. She advocates for a gentle approach, allowing pets to set the pace of interaction.
For instance, with a reserved cat, Estala would sit quietly, engaging the cat only when it felt comfortable enough to approach. Treats and catnip can facilitate this bonding, but it’s essential to know the pet’s preferences.
Patience is paramount; Estala shares an anecdote of a timid 16-year-old cat that took years to trust her. She emphasizes the importance of adapting care for senior pets, who may have different needs.
Learn more about In Your Place at jen64681.wixsite.com/inyourplacetc.
Mitten Kitten Cat Sitting
Anne Baker, co-owner of Mitten Kitten Cat Sitting, is dedicated exclusively to cats. Recognizing a niche in the market, her business emphasizes the unique personalities and needs of feline companions. Baker knows firsthand that every cat is distinct, from shy lap cats to playful chatterboxes.
Baker has observed transformative changes in her feline clients, including those recovering from trauma. Many owners refer to her as a “cat whisperer” due to her success in nurturing previously aloof cats.
Finding the Right Fit
Establishing trust with a pet sitter before your travel dates is essential. Early searches are advisable, especially during peak vacation seasons. Baker recommends a meet-and-greet to familiarize the sitter with the pet’s environment, routines, and dietary or medical needs.
This initial visit allows Baker to gather crucial information, ensuring a smooth transition in care. Owners are encouraged to fill out a detailed information and emergency release form for their cats, and many appreciate receiving daily updates and photos during their absence.
Learn more about Mitten Kitten at mittenkittencatsitting.com.
