Recently, we posed a question: What kind of stock market purge are we witnessing? In the month that followed, the stock market has provided many superficial answers, yet we remain in search of a definitive one.
Much like the political climate, the stock market excels in theatrics. Daily fluctuations leave observers perplexed, reacting erratically—much like a series of tweets from a notable figure.
Extreme volatility, marked by dramatic swings of several hundred points on the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA), has become commonplace. For instance, it might gain 300 points one day only to lose the same amount the next. Is anyone truly paying attention?
The cacophony coming from the stock market is deafening, filled with noise but lacking in meaningful insight.
After a lengthy nine-year bull market, the threat of a significant sell-off is glaringly obvious. We could see a decline akin to the harrowing 50 percent drop experienced during the 2008-09 financial crisis. But when will the next wave of fear strike?
Are the recent fluctuations signaling a market peak? The answer remains elusive. Remember that market peaks are often recognized only in hindsight and are part of a gradual process rather than a single occurrence. How should we interpret these signs?
Two Key Data Points to Monitor
While anyone can speculate endlessly about the factors leading to a potential market crash, here’s a straightforward list of concerns:
Interest rates trending upward, liquidity shrinking, a change in Fed leadership, quantitative tightening, rising tariffs and the threat of trade wars, geopolitical uncertainty, a new Congress, questionable celebrity influence, excessive market valuations, fragility in the economy, inflation, deflation, and much more.
Any one of these factors could justify fears of an imminent market downturn. Here at Economic Prism, we prefer simplicity. Thus, we propose two pivotal data points to watch:
The DJIA reached an all-time high of 26,616 on January 26, followed by a decline to an interim low of 23,360 on February 9. Since then, it has been erratically fluctuating.
It’s crucial to observe whether the DJIA breaks above its January high or dips below the February low first. If it crosses the February low, we might be looking at further declines—and a likely end to the bull market may be on the horizon.
One Fight Too Many
Over the past nine years, investors who embraced the ‘buy the dip’ strategy enjoyed considerable rewards. However, at some point, one of these dips will be the wrong choice, and a bounce will be the signal to sell.
The stock market has a humbling effect, capable of dismantling even the most successful investors’ track records. A portfolio built up over years can be obliterated in a bear market, sometimes without a chance for recovery.
Much like aging boxing champions who stay in the ring for one fight too many, investors can also lose their edge. The passage of time sneaks up on even the greatest of contenders, clouded by the allure of money and fame.
Some champions lose their drive, others lose their skill, and some lose both right when they need them most. Muhammad Ali’s 1980 fight with Larry Holmes serves as a cautionary tale; Ali, almost 40 and past his prime, fought out of financial necessity. A sports writer described it as, “…the worst sports event I ever had to cover.”
Perhaps Ali should have taken a bow while he was still ahead. Similarly, this could be a critical moment for investors to step back before they find themselves in a precarious situation.
A Lesson on Hubris
Bill Miller once believed he was smarter than the stock market, and with good reason. As the fund manager for the Legg Mason Value Trust, he outperformed the stock market for an astounding 15 consecutive years from 1991 to 2005—a feat unmatched in the industry.
Was his success due to profound intelligence, sheer luck, or a blend of both? Likely, it was a combination of diligent work, sharp instincts, and some fortuitous breaks.
By New Year’s Day 2006, Miller should have stepped away. He had proven his abilities and could have enjoyed a quieter life away from the pressure of the markets.
But like many seasoned fighters, Miller failed to recognize that the market had evolved while he had not. He unknowingly became a disaster waiting to happen.
The Consequences of Ignoring Warning Signs
When the market peaked in mid-2007, just before the crash, Miller found himself at a crossroads. With uncertainty rife in the fall of 2007, he adhered to his instinct and began buying aggressively. He employed a Martingale strategy, increasing his bets as prices fell. An article from Business Insider highlighted his facing off against market realities:
“Miller jumped at the chance to invest in companies like American International Group, Wachovia, Bear Stearns, and Freddie Mac, believing the market was overreacting. Unfortunately, what he thought was an opportunity became a catastrophic downturn—the largest since the Great Depression.”
From late 2007 to late 2008, the Legg Mason Value Trust plummeted nearly 60 percent, erasing years of gains. Assets under management dropped from $16.5 billion to $4.3 billion.
There are countless ways to squander $12.2 billion swiftly, from purchasing sports franchises to building extravagant hotels or even engaging in dubious ventures. However, Miller exemplified a lack of creativity—he simply eradicated $12.2 billion—a stark loss for countless investors who believed in him.
Reflecting on his failures, Miller stated, “Every decision to buy anything has been wrong.” There are indeed dense dips that should be avoided. The fall from mid-2007 to mid-2008 served as a prime example, and it’s quite possible that the next downturn will follow suit.
In conclusion, as we navigate the unpredictable tides of the stock market, it’s vital to remain vigilant and discerning. Today’s decisions can either cement your legacy or pave the way to potential disaster. Investors would do well to heed these lessons carefully.
Sincerely,
MN Gordon
for Economic Prism
Return from How to Blow $12.2 Billion in No Time Flat to Economic Prism
