The recently released September 2025 unemployment statistics from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) have sparked significant concern, especially following their delay due to a government shutdown.
At first glance, the numbers seem mildly encouraging. Nonfarm payrolls rose by 119,000. However, the unemployment rate nonetheless climbed to 4.4 percent.
Digging deeper, one uncovers a concerning statistic that contradicts the long-held belief in the value of a college education as a pathway to career prosperity. Shockingly, a record 25 percent of unemployed individuals in the U.S. now possess a four-year degree.
Conversely, this implies that 75 percent of those without jobs lack a college education. Yet, for anyone who has invested four years and substantial financial resources in gaining a degree, seeing such a statistic can be disheartening. Naturally, one might hope that the figure for unemployed individuals with degrees would align closer to zero.
Currently, one in four job seekers has pursued higher education believing it would secure their future, only to find themselves disillusioned. The traditional narrative of a college degree as a reliable ticket to the middle class has lost its power.
In September, the unemployment rate among those with bachelor’s degrees reached 2.8 percent, translating to over 1.9 million adults aged 25 and older who are unemployed — a historical high. The protective cocoon that a college degree once offered is now full of significant gaps.
Shifting Sands of the White-Collar World
For more than a century, college degrees in America served as a robust safety net, guaranteeing a clear trajectory from graduation to respectable white-collar employment. Today, that journey has become fraught with obstacles.
The disappointing statistics reflect not just a dearth of available jobs, but also a transformation in the nature of those jobs. Professional services, once a haven for new graduates, are in decline, as these sectors have seen a reduction in employment over the first nine months of 2025.
Conversely, the only sectors experiencing growth are in lower-paying healthcare/social assistance and leisure/hospitality roles — hardly the lucrative positions graduates envisioned when pursuing their degrees.
What lies behind this troubling trend for educated workers? The culprit appears to be a two-letter acronym: AI.
The swift integration of Artificial Intelligence into the workplace is more than just optimizing manufacturing; it is replacing numerous entry-level tasks with automation.
Traditional duties like report summarization, data entry, basic market research, and customer service are largely routine and repetitive — tasks that generative AI excels at completing with remarkable efficiency.
This technological shift is causing an unprecedented slowdown in white-collar employment. Companies are discovering that they can replicate the productivity of an entire team of junior employees simply by adopting AI tools, eliminating the necessity for human resources. With AI, there are no health benefits, no holiday pay, and no sick days or vacation requests.
While AI may not be eliminating all jobs just yet, it is certainly reducing the availability of entry-level positions.
The Experience Trap
With a reduction in entry-level positions, how are young professionals expected to gain the experience necessary for advancement? Where will they acquire the foundational skills that come from entry-level work?
Young workers, particularly, are facing significant challenges. In September, the unemployment rate for those aged 20 to 24 soared to 9.2 percent, a troubling figure usually associated with severe economic downturns. Compounding this issue is the burden of substantial student loan debt.
Recent graduates are grappling with feelings of betrayal, realizing that the rules they adhered to and the sacrifices they made were meant for a reality that no longer exists. Now they stand in unemployment lines alongside those without degrees, often encumbered by hefty financial liabilities.
In this scenario, a diploma can feel less like an accomplishment and more like a costly receipt for unmet expectations. The question arises: what comes next?
As millions of educated, ambitious young people find themselves at a standstill, the repercussions could be severe. Distrust is brewing toward the financial systems profiting from their student debt, the educational institutions that charged exorbitant tuition, and governmental bodies that appear to squander their future.
When a generation loses faith in the promises of the past, it can create fertile ground for social unrest. Frustration can escalate quickly, moving from expressing dissatisfaction online to more disruptive actions.
The once-reliable safety net of a college degree has a significant hole, and those young adults falling through it are likely to respond with urgency.
Where Will All the Cubicle Dwellers Go?
If a four-year degree no longer assures job security, what then is the new pathway to success?
The economic landscape is undergoing a radical transformation. Just as society shifted from agricultural to industrial and then to office-based careers, we are now navigating the challenging transition driven by AI.
This time, the shift is affecting traditional office environments. So where will today’s cubicle occupants find refuge?
As the initial rung on the corporate ladder fades, an entire generation might find themselves immobilized on the bottom step. Without securing their first job, they struggle to gain the experience needed for advancement, creating a cycle that may reinforce reliance on AI solutions and exacerbate the overall employment crisis.
Some will seek alternative means of income through gig economy jobs—driving for services like Uber or delivering meals. Others may depend on familial support well into their adulthood as they craft a backup plan, while some might choose to enter trade professions.
The ultimate fate of cubicle dwellers remains uncertain. Yet, what is strikingly clear is the dramatic shift in economic reality, one that cannot be reversed. A college degree alone no longer guarantees success. However, AI is not the sole answer.
AI still lacks the ability to replicate critical thinking and abstract reasoning. Genuine human creativity and intelligence cannot be replaced; it takes a person to launch a business, nurture relationships, develop products, bring them to market, and persuade consumers to buy.
AI may aid in these processes and execute tasks at a lower cost than humans, but it isn’t equipped to drive the complete spectrum of innovation needed to create wealth and opportunity.
A real, living person is still essential — degree or not.
[Editor’s note: Join the Economic Prism mailing list for a complimentary copy of an insightful report, “Utility Payment Wealth – Profit from Henry Ford’s Dream City Business Model.” Explore a special trial offer for MN Gordon’s Wealth Prism Letter, available here.]
Sincerely,
MN Gordon
for Economic Prism
Return from Where Will All the Cubicle Dwellers Go? to Economic Prism
