Protein is currently in the spotlight, transforming the landscape of food options available to consumers.
Fast food chains are unveiling an impressive selection of new protein-rich items. For instance, Starbucks launched a latte that boasts the same amount of protein as two quarter-pound hamburgers, and Chipotle has rolled out a dedicated high-protein menu. Grocery stores aren’t left behind either, as they now feature protein-fortified products ranging from breakfast waffles to cereal innovations.
These initiatives aim to attract the interest — and spending — of American consumers, who are increasingly craving protein.
News with a little more humanity
WPR’s “Wisconsin Today” newsletter keeps you connected to the state you love without feeling overwhelmed. No paywall. No agenda. No corporate filter.
A recent survey by the International Food Information Council revealed that 70% of Americans are trying to increase their protein intake, marking a rise from previous years. The trend shows no signs of slowing down.
In January, the U.S. Departments of Health and Human Services and Agriculture released new dietary guidelines advocating that Americans make protein a priority at every meal. This initiative aims to refocus dietary advice on “real food” as the cornerstone of the American diet.
The updated guidelines raise the recommended daily protein intake from 0.8 grams per kilogram of body weight to between 1.2 and 1.6 grams.
At a press conference marking the announcement, FDA Commissioner Marty Makary noted that the changes are rooted in scientific evidence rather than outdated beliefs.
“The former protein guidelines were simply intended to prevent malnutrition and weight loss,” Makary remarked. “These new guidelines are designed to ensure that American children can thrive.”
However, nutritionists across the nation have varying perspectives on this intensified focus on protein.
Ensuring Adequate Protein Intake
Alongside carbohydrates and fats, protein is recognized as an essential macronutrient crucial for the body’s growth, repair, and overall health.
According to Christopher Gardner, a professor of medicine at Stanford University, the American diet is generally not short on protein.
“Historically, Americans have consistently fallen short of calcium, potassium, fiber, and vitamin D,” Gardner stated. “However, protein has never appeared on that list of deficiencies.”
Gardner contributed to an advisory panel for two years, analyzing nutritional literature and providing insights as the new dietary guidelines were formulated.
Despite this, he believes that his contributions were disregarded due to alleged conflicts of interest among panelists. For instance, he had received funding from Beyond Meat, a plant-based meat company. This led to a new panel, appointed by Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., drafting its recommendations. Interestingly, several of these experts were found to have links to the beef and dairy industries.
“It’s astonishing that this was the narrative used to dismiss our recommendations,” Gardner remarked.
Under earlier guidelines, he asserted, Americans were already consuming ample protein. In fact, the U.S. ranks among the highest per capita meat consumers, making the new emphasis on protein perplexing, according to him.
“This focus comes at a concerning time,” Gardner observed, “as anyone visiting a store would notice that everything seems to be marketed as protein-rich.”
Corey Geiger, a dairy economist at CoBank, which specializes in rural infrastructure and agribusiness financing, offers insight into the rising demand for protein.
He notes that for years, the trend has gained traction on platforms like TikTok, evolving into a broader political agenda.
“Over the past few years, the MAHA movement has amplified the existing narrative,” Geiger explained.
Geiger co-authored a study revealing that brands can charge a 12% price premium for protein-packed products, illustrating how businesses are capitalizing on this growing trend.
Encouraging a Protein-Focused Consumer Culture
Cleveland Clinic dietitian Julia Zumpano agrees that companies will leverage protein’s rising popularity to promote products that may not be necessary.
“Historically, we’ve seen this happen with other diet trends, like the fat-free craze of the late 1990s,” she stated. “Every time a new diet trend emerges, it’s up to nutritionists to set the record straight.”
“While it’s concerning, education remains crucial,” Zumpano emphasized.
This educational effort includes advising on proper protein consumption, where many Americans may already exceed their needs without realizing it.
“Most Americans consume more calories than necessary,” Zumpano pointed out. “When this occurs, along with oversized portions, we tend to meet our protein requirements.”
The revised food pyramid prominently features animal-based proteins, including red meat, chicken, fish, and cheese, while only one plant-based protein is represented: beans.
Zumpano expresses uncertainty about why the guidelines emphasize animal sources over alternatives like chickpeas and soybeans. A balanced diet can incorporate various protein sources, including tofu, beans, and nuts. She cites the Mediterranean diet as an exemplary model.
“They eat red meat, cheese, and eggs,” Zumpano noted. “However, it’s in moderation and combined with various plant proteins.”
Some experts support the decision to raise the daily protein allowance. For instance, Stuart Phillips, a Kinesiology Professor at McMaster University, believes the previous recommendations were indeed too low.
Nonetheless, he argues that the new guidelines might overcorrect, pushing consumers toward protein-enhanced products that aren’t necessary.
“The new pyramid implies that protein should be consumed more frequently and in larger amounts,” Phillips stated. “Such an implication may not be beneficial.”
This story was produced in partnership with Harvest Public Media, a collaboration among public media newsrooms across the Midwest and Great Plains, focusing on food systems, agriculture, and rural issues.
