IBM’s Claude Code: A Test for Mainframe and AI Transition Confidence

Stay ahead of crucial updates on your stock portfolio and navigate the information overload. More than 7 million investors rely on Simply Wall St for essential insights at no cost.

Recently, IBM (NYSE:IBM) experienced its most significant single-day stock decline in over 25 years following the launch of Claude Code by Anthropic, an AI tool designed to automate the modernization of COBOL systems. This development has set off widespread discussions regarding the potential impact of AI tools on IBM’s longstanding mainframe and consulting services, particularly in relation to legacy COBOL applications.

• The news sparked broad debate about how AI tools could affect IBM’s long standing mainframe and consulting work tied to legacy COBOL applications.

• IBM is responding with its own modernization offerings and partnerships, as investors reassess the durability of a key revenue pillar.

At present, IBM’s shares are priced at $242.01, following a 17.6% drop over the past month and a 17.0% decline year-to-date. In contrast, the stock has yielded a remarkable 108.1% return over the last three years and an impressive 157.5% return over five years, offering context as the market grapples with new pressures related to AI on its fundamental business.

For investors monitoring NYSE:IBM, the launch by Anthropic underscores the swift encroachment of AI tools into traditionally IBM-dominated domains, such as large-scale COBOL modernization projects. The critical question now revolves around how effectively IBM can deploy its offerings and partnerships to maintain the relevance of its established mainframe and consulting relationships amidst emerging alternatives.

Stay informed on the latest news surrounding International Business Machines by adding it to your watchlist or portfolio. For additional insights, explore our Community section for diverse perspectives on International Business Machines.

Discover insider trading activities at International Business Machines following these developments.

For current and potential investors, the steep one-day decline in IBM’s shares appears less a judgment on recent performance and more a rapid re-evaluation of expectations concerning AI competition. The selloff was prompted by concerns that Anthropic’s Claude Code might shorten multi-year COBOL modernization projects—traditionally involving IBM mainframes and consulting services—into less lucrative, shorter engagements. Despite this, IBM has secured new contracts, including a $112 million ceiling agreement with the Department of War’s Defense Commissary Agency, and is expanding its AI collaborations, like integrating Deepgram’s voice capabilities into watsonx Orchestrate. This juxtaposition of strong recent operational performance against the stock’s reaction suggests that investor sentiment is influenced more by perceived disruption risks than by a decline in demand. Analyst opinions are varied; some believe the AI-related fears are exaggerated, while others caution that volatility may continue until more definitive evidence emerges regarding software growth, cash flows, and the effects of Claude Code on client behaviors regarding mainframe workloads.

• The Claude Code development connects to the broader narrative that IBM’s push into AI and hybrid cloud services—coupled with a growing portfolio of AI partnerships—could foster revenue growth as clients modernize their IT infrastructures. This highlights the increasing importance of effective software execution.

• The risk that AI tools might reduce the need for intensive COBOL modernization services challenges the perception that IBM’s mainframe and consulting divisions can smoothly support its transition, intensifying demands on the company to demonstrate that products like watsonx Code Assistant maintain its relevance in modernization efforts.

• The scale of the single-day stock movement and subsequent revisions of analyst ratings underscore a specific level of disruption risk associated with AI that goes beyond a straightforward narrative of gradual growth driven by hybrid cloud and quantum advancements.

Understanding a company’s valuation is rooted in comprehending its overarching narrative. Explore one of the prominent narratives in the Simply Wall St Community regarding International Business Machines to aid in determining its value to you.

• ⚠️ AI tools like Claude Code increase the risk of modernization projects related to legacy COBOL systems on IBM platforms becoming less reliant on consulting services, threatening a long-established revenue source that investors have considered stable.

• ⚠️ Analysts have identified a significant risk tied to IBM’s financial structure, notably its high level of debt, which could constrain flexibility if cash flows from mainframe and consulting sectors deteriorate quicker than anticipated.

• 🎁 Despite the volatility, IBM continues to offer a dividend of approximately 2.78% with a payout ratio below 50%, providing a potential source of stability for investors amid uncertainties related to AI disruption risks.

• 🎁 Earnings are projected to grow by 7.21% annually and have reportedly increased by 75.7% over the last year, alongside a share price trading approximately 37.4% below a fair value estimate, attracting investors who perceive the recent market fluctuations as a reset rather than a fundamental breakdown.

Looking ahead, critical inquiries revolve around whether IBM can retain mainframe-related workloads as clients experiment with Claude Code and similar applications, as well as how swiftly its own AI and automation solutions translate into deal acquisitions and reported software growth. Stakeholders may also concentrate on contract activities, such as the $112 million Defense Commissary Agency contract, and collaborations in quantum computing and voice AI, alongside management and client insights on how generative AI is reshaping modernization project parameters. Market movements and analyst adjustments will give real-time feedback on whether recent fluctuations are perceived as an isolated AI-related scare or the beginning of a prolonged reassessment against competitors like Microsoft, Oracle, and Amazon Web Services.

To keep updated on how the latest developments affect the investment narrative for International Business Machines, visit the community page for International Business Machines to ensure you never miss critical updates on key community narratives.

This article by Simply Wall St is intended to provide general information. Our commentary is based on historical data and analyst forecasts utilizing an unbiased methodology; it should not be construed as financial advice. We do not recommend buying or selling any stocks and do not consider your objectives or financial situation. Our aim is to deliver long-term focused analyses driven by fundamental data. Please note that our insights may not incorporate the most recent price-sensitive announcements or qualitative information. Simply Wall St holds no positions in any of the stocks mentioned.

The companies featured in this article include IBM.

If you have feedback on this article or concerns regarding the content, let us know directly. You can also email editorial-team@simplywallst.com