During a recent gathering in Paris, European Central Bank (ECB) President Mario Draghi emphatically responded “no, absolutely not” when asked by Le Monde whether the euro was at risk. This moment was a stark reminder of the underlying dynamics of European finance.
Understanding how the world operates often hinges on recognizing certain fundamental truths. Certain adages can provide incredible insight and a significant edge in navigating life. For instance, the saying, “A fool and his money are soon parted,” unveils a wisdom that can give a person a leg up over almost 90% of the population. Likewise, the adage “never stiff the IRS” can save an individual from a world of trouble, avoiding penalties and possibly even jail time.
As Draghi’s remarks illustrate, there’s a well-worn expression that encapsulates a key truth:
“How can you tell when a politician is lying?”
“His lips are moving.”
This brings us to a critical realization: when a politician or a central banker confidently states a definitive answer, one should often expect the opposite outcome. The euro’s future does not rest solely in the hands of Draghi or other Eurozone officials—it is ultimately determined by the market.
Is There Any Money in the EU Kitty?
Recently, Spain’s debt has become a hot topic, resembling a raging wildfire in Malibu. Last Friday, 10-year Spanish bonds exceeded 7% for the second consecutive day, climbing to over 7.5%—the highest level since the euro’s inception. Notably, yields surpassing 7% are typically viewed as unmanageable, making it near impossible for a country to issue new bonds to pay off existing debt. Without a drop in borrowing costs, Madrid risks losing access to crucial credit markets.
Moreover, despite an agreement among Eurozone finance ministers to extend rescue loans of 100 billion euros (approximately $122 billion) to Spanish banks, the country’s debt continues to escalate. There is a prevailing sense of skepticism that these bailouts will effectively resolve the debt crisis. Clearly, the situation in Spain is deteriorating, while the European Central Bank seems poised to retreat.
“Demand for Spanish paper is collapsing, even for shorter-dated debt, which is alarming and raises concerns about Spain losing market access,” said Nicholas Spiro from Spiro Sovereign Strategy.
Marchel Alexandrovich from Jefferies Fixed Income expressed that markets are bracing for a potentially larger bailout of about 400 billion euros. “If this trend continues, Madrid may conclude it has no other option but to request a full sovereign bailout. We’ll then discover whether there truly is any money in the EU’s reserve,” he noted.
“If the ECB opts to remain inactive, it could lead to a significant escalation. We’re well past the point where individual nations can enact fiscal measures independently. Regardless of subsequent actions, investors will likely hesitate to purchase Spanish and Italian debt. There must be a decisive intervention,” he added.
A Valuable Lesson on Money Creation
The critical intervention that Spain, Draghi, and the Eurozone are relying upon is Germany. Specifically, it hinges on the German people’s savings and their government’s willingness to utilize those funds to support Spain and other nations in need. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has expressed its reservations regarding this reliance.
In its annual report on the Eurozone, the IMF highlighted that the escalating crisis raises doubts about the “viability of the monetary union itself.” It cautioned that the “negative connections between sovereigns, banks, and the real economy are increasingly pronounced.”
The report deemed the current structure of the Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) “unsustainable” and called for a comprehensive policy shift, including aggressive monetary strategies by the ECB, the establishment of a banking union, and debt pooling.
However, this appeal starkly contrasts the sentiment within the Bundestag, where bailout fatigue has reached a critical point. “We set red lines, only to breach them. We cannot continue like this,” stated Mr. Steinmeier, Leader of the Social Democratic Party of Germany.
“It’s an infinite abyss,” stated Free-Democrat (FDP) spokesman Frank Schäffler, a sentiment likely shared by many Germans.
Consequently, when Germany ultimately withdraws financial support from Spain, Draghi and the ECB may find themselves compelled to initiate another Long Term Refinancing Operation (LTRO). Recall that the last two LTRO operations between December 2011 and March 2012 injected $672 billion into the European financial system, yet their impact was short-lived. As Schäffler observed, “it’s a bottomless pit.”
On a positive note, the ECB is gaining valuable experience as they navigate this complex landscape. Their recent realization is that once initiated, operations involving money creation are far more difficult to halt than to commence.
In conclusion, the interplay of political decisions, market reactions, and economic realities continues to shape the future of the Eurozone. The lessons learned during these tumultuous times may prove invaluable for navigating similar challenges in the future.
Sincerely,
MN Gordon
for Economic Prism
Return from A Valuable Lesson on Money Creation to Economic Prism