As February rolls around, you find yourself picking up a box of inexpensive Valentine’s chocolates during your lunch break. Later, while enjoying them at your desk, you notice someone watching you. A wave of embarrassment washes over you, prompting you to stash the box away. You might make a joke or wish you hadn’t been seen—not due to the taste of the chocolate, but because you dread being judged for your choice.
If this scenario resonates with you, you’re certainly not alone. Many individuals experience subtle feelings of embarrassment or self-consciousness regarding their everyday consumption choices, whether it’s indulging in low-cost Valentine’s chocolates, accepting a free lunch from a school food program, or having visible tattoos.
We are social marketing researchers focused on the concept of stigma in marketing. Our research has introduced the term “consumption stigma,” which describes how individuals may face judgment from others, or even from themselves, for their product choices—despite there being nothing objectively wrong with those products.
Understanding Consumption Stigma
When individuals feel scrutinized for what they consume—or choose not to consume—the impact can be mentally draining. Being stigmatized can gradually diminish self-esteem, heighten anxiety, and alter how people behave in everyday situations. What begins as a fleeting moment of embarrassment may develop into a chronic concern about appearing “wrong” to others.
In reviewing 50 studies related to stigma in marketing, we found that people react to consumption stigma along a spectrum. Some individuals attempt to completely avoid stigma by hiding their consumption or steering clear of certain products. Others modify their behavior to mitigate the chances of being judged. At one extreme, some actively resist stigma, working towards destigmatizing particular forms of consumption for themselves and others.
The studies indicate that individuals may opt for more expensive or socially favored alternatives to avoid stigma, even if it strains their budgets. For instance, someone might decide to purchase a premium chocolate brand simply to sidestep embarrassment, regardless of their actual preference for the taste.
Over time, these adjustments can create spending habits that exceed one’s means, perpetuating a cycle of consumption driven more by societal pressure than by actual need or pleasure. We believe this issue can manifest even more acutely in different contexts—like when a child avoids a free school lunch out of fear of teasing, or when a veteran declines mental health support due to anticipated judgment.
From a business standpoint, when consumers avoid or reject products to escape stigma, companies may experience a drop in demand that has little to do with the product’s quality or value. If consumption stigma becomes widespread, its cumulative effect could lead to lost revenue and diminished brand equity.
Therefore, understanding consumption stigma is crucial not only for consumer well-being but also for businesses seeking to grasp why people may choose to buy, conceal, or abandon certain products.
PixelsEffect/E+ via Getty Images
Reclaiming the Narrative
Stigma often seems overwhelming because it masquerades as an accepted reality. However, consumption stigma fundamentally represents a social judgment—a collective narrative about what certain choices purportedly indicate about a person. When this narrative goes unexamined, stigma endures. Conversely, questioning it can diminish its influence.
One effective way to combat stigma is by reclaiming the narrative around personal consumption. Instead of hiding or justifying their choices, people can stand confidently behind them. This transformation from avoidance to acceptance can weaken the hold of stigma.
Consider a shopper who proudly opts for economical store brands at the supermarket. She views this decision not as a compromise, but as a savvy choice that enables her to save money. When individuals embrace their decisions—whether it’s indulging in inexpensive chocolate, wearing secondhand clothing, or seeking specialized health services—they diminish the perceived negativity. Once a behavior is no longer considered shameful, it grows more difficult for others to use it as a basis for judgment.
Undeniably, stigma does not vanish overnight. Yet, research indicates that when enough individuals stop concealing a behavior, its social implications begin to shift. What feels awkward in one moment may become completely normal in another. For example, studies on fashion consumption have illustrated how wearing a veil, once stigmatized in urban, secular environments, gradually became recognized as commonplace and even stylish as more women began embracing it.
Enjoying inexpensive chocolate shouldn’t necessitate a defense. Drinking cold water from a generic travel mug is just as refreshing as sipping from a fancy Stanley tumbler. A no-name sweatshirt offers equal comfort as a designer counterpart. Still, many people feel compelled to rationalize, downplay, or upgrade their choices to escape judgment. Recognizing consumption stigma elucidates these feelings, highlighting that they are not personal shortcomings, but rather societal constructs.
Sometimes, the most powerful response is not to alter consumption habits, but to shift one’s perspective. When individuals cease to regard everyday choices as moral indicators, they pave the way for a more compassionate—and ultimately honest—marketplace.
